Tuesday, April 1, 2008

Blog Assignment 8

For this week's blog compare Chretien de Troye's "The Knight of the Cart" to the Lais of Marie de France. How are they different/similar? Is there a significant change in the perspective of the authors? Which do you like better and why?

2 comments:

KFung said...

The obvious difference between The Knight of the Cart and the Lais of Marie de France is that The Knight of the Cart is a much longer narrative than the quick short Lais. However, I feel that because Marie de France's Lais are short, there is a lot of information given at one time than with Knight of Cart. For example, when we discussed on Wednesday how the two texts describe the people in the stories, Marie de France's Lais gives a lot of detail to looks and desirable traits and family ties, while Knight of Cart is not as focused on appearance details as Lais.

Both of these text deal with love and for the most part they deal with the love of adulterers. I feel that in Knight of Cart the love between Lancelot and Gwenivere is handled as more of a narrative account of their true love quest to be together. With the Lais, Marie de France writes almost like an Aesop's Fables of love. Each little story centers around the love conflicts between two people, one of which usually is married to someone else. I feel that at the end of each story, there is a moral to it, giving insight to what Marie de France probably thought about love.

I personally liked the Lais better than Knight of Cart because its fast paced storyline makes it easier to read and the messages read clearer. The only thing that I was confused with was that in several of the stories, the adulterers usually don't end well but with the first story the characters end up together in a 'true love prevails all' kind of situation. Why the change in perspective from the author?

katie ross said...

“The Knight of the Cart” and Marie de France “Lais” are similar in the way that they both concern themselves with love and adultery. In both texts, we as readers do not see adultery presented in question of its being right or wrong. Rather, we see passion and Love in the heroes and heroines' actions. However, “The Knight of the Cart” throws in a third element with Logic. While reasoning is incorporated in “The Knight of the Cart”, the protagonists are driven solely by Love (often to an unreasonable degree). Adultery becomes a justified action in both accounts, if done for Love (especially if the damsel is locked away against her will). Personally I liked Marie de France better, although I found the descriptions very epic and unrealistic, in a way it was pleasantly distracting.